Records vs. Other Currently Ranked Teams
If teams are going to a be ranked solely by wins and losses how about if we sorted them the same way but excluded wins over teams that aren't ranked?
The CFP field will include 12 of these and almost certainly exclude Texas.
4-1 Georgia
3-0 TT (BYU twice and UTAH + bad loss)
-
3-2 Texas
Wins over current #7, #8 and #13
Losses to current #2 and #3
+ bad loss
-
3-2 Oklahoma (lost to Texas)
3-2 Alabama (+ bad loss)
2-0 Indiana
2-1 OSU
2-1 A&M (lost to Texas)
2-1 Ole Miss
1-1 Oregon
1-0 Miami (+ two bad losses)
1-2 Vandy (lost to Texas)
1-2 BYU
0-2 Notre Dame
0-1 Tulane (+ bad loss)
0-0 James Madison (+ bad loss)
So, there are teams at the bottom here with no serious wins and Miami's win was over Notre Dame.
Alabama has a bad loss to Florida State. Alabama lost to Oklahoma who lost to Texas. So, the committee is saying that Texas bad loss to Florida trumps everything else.
They are also sending a clear message that big wins and big game record don't matter.
Line up the cupcakes, please.
If the tournament was 16 teams, these would probably be them. If I was picking 12 teams solely to have the very best tournament, I'd kick out Miami, Notre Dame, Tulane and James Madison. BYU sneaks in and who doesn't want to see Vandy in? But they won't make it, either.
Final question. Is Texas one of the 12 best teams in the country? Yes.